Skillful Poor
GPT.icon The phrase "Jack of all trades and master of none " (kiyōbinbō) is an interesting aspect of Japanese culture. kiyō) translates to "skillful" or "adroit", referring to someone who is capable of handling many different tasks or fields. "poor" (binbō) means "[ poor", indicating the lack of wealth or success. The phrase is often used to describe a person who, while capable in many areas, fails to excel in any one particular field. This lack of specialization, it implies, keeps them from achieving substantial success or wealth. This is reflected in the idiom's rough translation: "skillful but poor".
In comparison, the English phrase "jack of all trades, master of none" also describes a person with a wide array of skills but without a specialization. However, there are some nuanced differences between the two phrases. While the English idiom doesn't necessarily imply failure or poverty, it carries an underlying suggestion that a person might be better off if they specialized in something. It's more of a caution against spreading oneself too thin.
In the context of Japanese culture, which often values deep expertise and mastery in a single area, this term suggests that a lack of specialization can directly lead to a lack of success or financial stability. In the context of Japanese culture, which often values deep expertise and mastery in a single area, this term suggests that a lack of specialization can directly lead to a lack of success or financial stability.
The understanding of both phrases certainly depends on cultural context. Yet they both speak to a universal tension between being broadly competent versus being highly specialized.
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/Skillful Poor using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.